Checklist
How to check if a company is legit before you reply, pay or share data
To check if a company is legit, confirm that the sender's email domain matches a real website, that the domain is not brand new, that the message passes SPF, DKIM and DMARC, and that the company exists in an official business register under the same name. Before any payment, confirm bank details by calling a phone number you found yourself, never one from the message.
Updated November 17, 2026 ยท 13 min read
Key takeaways
- The first five checks take under ten minutes and catch most fake or impersonated senders: address vs domain, lookalike domains, domain age, email authentication, and the website.
- Passing SPF, DKIM and DMARC proves the email came from that domain, not that the domain belongs to an honest company. A scammer's own lookalike domain can pass all three.
- An official register lookup (Secretary of State, Companies House, EU national registers) and a VAT check confirm the legal entity behind the brand.
- The costliest fraud is not a fake vendor but a fake message from a real one: changed bank details. A call-back rule stops it.
- Download the checklist as a CSV that opens in Excel and Google Sheets, and keep one filled copy per new supplier.
How deep to check: match the effort to the risk
Not every cold offer needs a full investigation. Decide by what you are about to do next:
| Your next step | Risk | Checks to run |
|---|---|---|
| Reply, or file the offer for later | Low | 1 to 5 (about 10 minutes) |
| Click a link, open an attachment, book a call | Medium | 1 to 5, plus 10 and 11 |
| Share company data, sign an NDA, give system access | High | 1 to 13 |
| Pay a first invoice or a deposit, or change payment details | Highest | All 15, including the call-back rule |
For a supplier you are formally onboarding (contracts, insurance, security questionnaires), this checklist is the first gate; continue with the vendor due diligence checklist.
The 15-point vendor verification checklist
1. Compare the sender address with the company domain
Look at the actual address, not the display name. On a phone, tap the sender name to reveal it. A company that claims a team, offices and clients but writes from a free webmail account is a warning sign. Also check the Reply-To address: if you hit reply and the "To" field changes to a different domain, the reply goes somewhere other than the sender shown.
2. Look for lookalike domains
Read the domain one character at a time. Common tricks: rn instead of m, 0 instead of o, l instead of I, an added hyphen or word (acme-billing.com), a different ending (.co instead of .com), or a real brand as a subdomain of someone else's domain (acme.com.payments-portal.net, where the real domain is the last part before the path). For an existing supplier, compare against an older email from them in your inbox.
3. Check the domain age (WHOIS / RDAP)
Look up the domain in a WHOIS or RDAP lookup; ICANN runs a free lookup tool, and many registrars offer one. Find the creation or registration date. A company claiming ten years in business on a domain registered last month needs a good explanation. Owner names are often hidden for privacy, which is normal and not a red flag on its own; the date is what matters.
4. Read SPF, DKIM and DMARC results in the message headers
Your mail provider records whether the message was authorized by the domain it claims to come from. Steps for Gmail and Outlook are below. What to look for: dmarc=pass with the same domain as the From address. A fail on a message claiming to be from a well known company is a strong signal of spoofing. A pass only proves the email came from that domain, so combine it with checks 2 and 3.
5. Do a website reality check
Type the domain yourself instead of clicking links in the email. A real business site usually has: a specific description of what they do and for whom, named people, a postal address, a legal entity name (often in the footer, terms or privacy policy), and a contact page that matches the email you received. Warning signs: a site that does not load, a parked domain page, an unedited template with placeholder text, stock photos of a "team", no legal name anywhere, or a site much newer than the claimed company history. PitchBin runs this check automatically on every offer forwarded to save@pitchbin.com: it checks the sender's website and flags offers sent from addresses with no real site behind them.
6. Look the company up in an official business register
Search the legal entity name (from the website footer, invoice or contract) in the official register of the country it claims. Confirm three things: it exists, it is active (not dissolved or struck off), and the registered address and directors are consistent with what you were told. See the register table below. In the UK, Companies House search is free and shows status, filing history, officers and registered address.
7. Validate the VAT number (EU and UK)
For a supplier in the EU, check the VAT number on the European Commission's VIES VAT number validation service. Depending on the country, VIES returns whether the number is valid and may show the registered name and address; that name should match the company on the invoice. UK (GB) VAT numbers are no longer in VIES after Brexit (Northern Ireland "XI" numbers are the exception); use HMRC's "Check a UK VAT number" service on GOV.UK instead.
8. Check the physical address
Put the address into a map with street view. A virtual office or registered agent address is common for small and remote companies and is not proof of fraud, but it should not be described as "our headquarters with 80 staff". The same address appearing for dozens of unrelated companies in the register is worth a second look.
9. Call the company on a number you found yourself
Use the phone number from the official register, the company's long-standing website, or a previous contract, not the signature in the email. Ask the switchboard to put you through to the person who contacted you. A real company can usually confirm an employee in one call.
10. Compare LinkedIn presence with the claims
Check the company page and the people who list it as their employer. Does the number of employees roughly match the claimed size? Does the sender have a profile with a history longer than a few weeks, connections in the industry, and the same job title as in the email? A brand new company page, a single employee, or profiles with generated-looking photos and no activity are warning signs. Absence alone is not proof of fraud: some small specialist firms barely use LinkedIn.
11. Read reviews and search for complaints
Search the company name with words like "scam", "complaint", "fraud" and "reviews". Look at review sites relevant to the industry and at the dates of reviews: a burst of five-star reviews in one week is weaker evidence than a steady history. For regulated services, check the regulator's register: for example, financial firms in the UK should appear on the FCA register, and the FCA publishes a warning list of firms to avoid.
12. Ask for references and contact them yourself
Ask for two clients of similar size who used the same service in the last year. Find those clients' contact details independently (their website or switchboard) rather than using the email addresses the vendor gives you, which can be controlled by the vendor. A legitimate vendor rarely refuses; one that cannot name a single checkable client is not ready for your money.
13. Screen against sanctions lists before paying abroad
For international payments, check the company and its owners against official sanctions lists, such as the US Treasury's OFAC sanctions list search and the UK sanctions list published by the government. Your bank may also screen payments, but the obligation not to deal with sanctioned parties applies to your company too.
14. Match the bank account to the legal entity
The account holder name on the invoice should be the same legal entity you verified in step 6, in the country where the company is registered or operates. Payments requested to a personal account, an account in an unrelated country, gift cards or cryptocurrency are red flags, whatever the explanation.
15. Apply the call-back rule to any change in payment details
If any message, even from a supplier you have paid for years, asks you to pay a new account, confirm it by phone using a number from your own records before paying. This one rule addresses the most expensive scenario on this page, explained next.
How to view email headers in Gmail and Outlook
Gmail (web)
- Open the message on a computer (the Gmail mobile app does not offer this view).
- Click the three-dot More menu next to Reply and choose Show original.
- At the top, Gmail lists SPF, DKIM and DMARC, each with PASS or FAIL and the domain checked.
- Quick alternative: click the small arrow under the sender's name. The mailed-by and signed-by lines show which domains sent and signed the message.
Outlook on the web and the new Outlook for Windows
- Open the message and click the More actions (three dots) menu.
- Choose View and then View message details.
- Find the line that starts with Authentication-Results.
Classic Outlook for Windows
- Double-click the message to open it in its own window.
- Click File and then Properties.
- The headers are in the Internet headers box; search it for Authentication-Results.
How to read the result
- dmarc=pass and header.from equal to the domain you see in the From line: the domain authorized this message. Good, but check the domain itself (steps 2 and 3).
- dmarc=fail on a message from a major brand or your known supplier: treat as spoofed. Do not click, reply or pay.
- spf=pass for a different domain than the From line: the sending service is authorized for itself, not for the brand shown. Look at DMARC, which checks alignment.
- none or missing results: the domain has not set up authentication. Common for tiny or new businesses, unusual for an established one.
- Forwarded messages can show SPF failures even when legitimate. Check the original message, not a forward.
Where to look up a company: official registers by country
| Country | Official source | What you can confirm |
|---|---|---|
| United States | Business entity search of the Secretary of State (or equivalent office) in the state of formation; SEC EDGAR for public companies | Legal name, status (active, dissolved), formation date, registered agent |
| United Kingdom | Companies House | Status, registered office, officers, filing history, persons with significant control |
| European Union | The national business register of each member state; the EU e-Justice portal offers a cross-border company search | Registration number, legal form, status, registered address |
| EU VAT | VIES (European Commission) | Whether a VAT number is valid; in many countries the name and address |
| UK VAT | HMRC "Check a UK VAT number" on GOV.UK | Whether a GB VAT number is valid and the registered business name |
| Canada | Corporations Canada for federal companies; the provincial registry for others | Status, registered office, directors |
| Australia | ABN Lookup and the ASIC registers | ABN status, entity name, GST registration |
The name on the website ("Acme Digital") and the legal name in the register ("Acme Media Holdings Ltd") often differ. That is normal. What is not normal is a website, invoice and bank account that each point to a different entity.
Bank detail change fraud (business email compromise)
Business email compromise (BEC) is when a criminal sends a convincing message, from a hacked or lookalike mailbox of a real supplier or executive, asking you to pay a "new" bank account or to rush a transfer. The FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) reports BEC as one of the costliest types of internet crime in the United States year after year, with reported losses in the billions of dollars. In the UK, the National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) and Action Fraud both warn businesses about invoice and mandate fraud of this kind.
What makes BEC hard to spot: the email may come from the supplier's real address (if their mailbox was hacked), may reply inside a genuine thread, quote real invoice numbers, and pass every header check. That is why the defense is a process, not a judgment call.
The call-back rule
- Any request to change bank details, or to pay an unusual amount urgently, is confirmed by phone before payment.
- The phone number comes from your own records (contract, vendor file, earlier invoice, official register), never from the message asking for the change.
- You speak to a person you already know at the supplier, or ask the switchboard for accounts receivable.
- A second person in your company approves the change after the call.
- The first payment to new details is held for a short period or split, if your process allows.
Script for the call:
Ask them to read the details to you, not the other way around. Then tell suppliers your policy so they expect it:
Red flags table
| Red flag | Why it matters | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Urgency or secrecy ("must go out today", "keep this between us") | Pressure is designed to skip your checks | Slow down. Run the call-back rule. |
| Changed bank details by email | The classic BEC move | Call a known number before paying |
| Lookalike domain | Impersonation of a real company | Compare character by character with older emails |
| Reply-To differs from From | Your reply goes to someone else | Start a new email to the known address |
| Domain registered weeks ago | Conflicts with any claimed history | Ask why; check the register |
| DMARC fail on a known brand | Likely spoofed | Do not click or reply; report it |
| No website, or a template site with no legal name | No accountable business behind the offer | Ask for the registration number |
| Not in the register, or dissolved | No legal entity to contract with | Do not proceed |
| Invoice for something you never ordered (directory listing, domain "renewal", ad space) | A common scam on businesses | Check your records; do not pay "to be safe" |
| Payment by gift card, crypto, or to a personal or foreign account | Hard or impossible to recover | Refuse; pay only the verified entity |
| Large upfront fee before any work | You carry all the risk | Offer milestones or a small paid pilot |
| Refuses a video call or a callback to a main line | Real people at real companies take calls | Treat as unverified |
| Attachment that asks you to enable macros or log in | Malware or credential theft | Do not open; ask your IT team |
Checking a cold offer without wasting your afternoon
Most cold offers are from real, if pushy, companies. The goal is not to investigate each one, but to separate the plausible ones from the junk quickly and keep the plausible ones findable. A workable routine:
- Run checks 1 to 5 on anything you might reply to.
- Delete and report anything that fails them.
- File the rest in one shared place with the company, service and price, so the next time someone needs that service, the team starts from a list rather than a search. Forwarding to save@pitchbin.com does the filing and the website check in one step.
- Run the full checklist only when an offer becomes a real purchase.
For replies, use the templates in how to respond to a cold email; for pitches that arrive on LinkedIn, see how to respond to LinkedIn sales messages. When you get to choosing between vendors, the vendor evaluation criteria and scorecard picks up where this page ends.
Frequently asked questions
How can I tell if a business email is legit?
Check that the address uses the company's own domain, that the domain is not a lookalike or newly registered, and that the headers show dmarc=pass for that domain. Then confirm anything involving money by calling a number you found yourself.
Does passing SPF, DKIM and DMARC mean an email is safe?
No. It means the domain authorized the message. A scammer can register a lookalike domain and pass all three, and a hacked real mailbox also passes. Treat a pass as one check among several.
How do I verify a company is registered?
Search its legal name in the official register: the Secretary of State business search in the US state of formation, Companies House in the UK, or the national register in EU countries. Confirm it is active and the address matches.
How do I check an EU VAT number?
Use the European Commission's VIES service. Enter the country and number; it shows whether the number is valid and, for many countries, the registered name and address. UK GB numbers are checked on GOV.UK instead.
What should I do if a supplier emails new bank details?
Do not pay until you have called the supplier on a number from your own records and confirmed the change with a person you know. Have a second person approve the update.
Where do I report a fake vendor or invoice scam?
In the US, the FBI's IC3 and the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. In the UK, Action Fraud or Police Scotland, and forward phishing emails to report@phishing.gov.uk. Contact your bank immediately if money was sent.
Is a company without a website automatically a scam?
Not automatically, but it is a strong warning sign for anyone selling business services. Ask for a registration number and references, and do not pay upfront until those check out.
Keep reading
Let the first check run itself.
Forward cold offers to save@pitchbin.com. PitchBin checks the sender's website, flags offers without one, and files the rest with company, service and price. Free for buyers.