How to use it
- Name the unit you are buying (article, user, ticket, site visit) so every quote turns into a real cost per unit.
- Enter each quote in its own pricing model. Do not convert anything by hand: a retainer, a project fee and an hourly rate can sit side by side.
- Add the fine print: one-off fees, recurring extras such as licenses or travel, minimum term, notice, auto-renewal and the yearly increase. Leave a field empty when the quote is silent and enter 0 when you checked and there is no cost.
- Pick the horizon (12, 24 or 36 months) and, if you want to see the lock-in, the month at which you might leave.
- Score the non-price criteria 1 to 5, read the ranking, then copy the questions for each vendor and send them.
What the numbers mean
Total cost is everything you would pay over the horizon for the same outcome: one-off fees, the base price for every month (or every project started), recurring extras and the yearly price increase from month 13. It is the number to compare, not the headline price.
Headline vs real cost per unit. The headline is what the quote seems to say (a $22,000 project for 48 articles is $458.33 per article). The real cost divides the total by the units you actually get. In the worked example, that turns the cheapest-looking quote into the most expensive fixed one.
Committed after the horizon appears when a minimum term is longer than the period you are comparing. A 12-month view of a 24-month contract hides half of what you are signing.
Still owed if you stop at month N is the rest of the minimum term (or of the current auto-renewal period, or of the current project) that you would pay even after you stop using the vendor, assuming you gave notice in time. The row below shows the extra cost if you only give notice at month N.
Break-even hours appear for hourly quotes. They show how many hours per unit the vendor can take before it stops being cheaper than the next best quote. If the break-even is close to the vendor's own estimate, a small overrun changes the winner, so ask for a not-to-exceed cap.
What to enter for each pricing model
| Model | Base price | Quantity | How the total is built |
| Monthly retainer | Retainer per month | Units delivered per month | Retainer x months, increased yearly |
| Project fee | Fee per project | Units per project, project length | Fee x projects started in the horizon, plus per-project extras such as workshops or travel |
| Hourly | Hourly rate | Units per month, hours per unit, management overhead, optional cap | Units x hours x (1 + overhead) x rate x months, limited by the cap |
| Per seat | Price per seat per month | Seats | Seats x price x months |
| Per unit | Price per unit | Units per month | Units x price x months |
Compare all quotes exclusive of sales tax or VAT, and in one currency. If the quotes arrive in different currencies, convert them at one rate on one date first; the calculator warns you when the currencies do not match.
How the weighted score works
Price becomes a score by formula, not by feel: price score = 5 x lowest total / this vendor's total. The cheapest quote gets 5 and the others get proportionally less, so a quote 10 percent more expensive scores about 4.5. Every other criterion is scored 1 to 5 by you. The weighted score is the sum of each score times its weight, divided by the total weight.
The default weights (price 40, quality 25, delivery 15, risk 10, relationship 10) suit most service purchases. Commodity purchases usually weight price higher, specialist advice lower; the typical weightings by purchase type are in the guide, and a fuller list of criteria is in vendor evaluation criteria. Treat a gap under about 0.2 points as a tie: it is a reason to negotiate, not a verdict.
Best practice
- Fix the basis first. Same scope, same quantity, same service level for every vendor. If one vendor changes the scope, ask everyone to requote.
- Look at two horizons. Twelve months shows what you sign; 36 months shows renewal increases and amortized setup fees. The ranking often flips between them.
- Treat estimates as estimates. Change the hours per unit by 20 percent and watch the totals. If the winner changes, you need a cap.
- Send the questions in writing to every vendor with the same deadline, then update the numbers and decide. Record why you chose, and tell the others with a short note (see vendor rejection letter templates).
- Keep the original quotes. The price you compared is only useful if you can show it again at renewal time.
Prefer a spreadsheet? The same method, with the worked example pre-filled, is in the quote comparison CSV, which opens in Excel and Google Sheets.
Frequently asked questions
How do I compare quotes with different pricing models?
Enter each quote in its own model and let the calculator convert them into total cost over the same horizon and cost per unit of output. A retainer, a project fee and an hourly rate become directly comparable once one-off fees, extras and price increases are added.
What is total cost of ownership for a vendor quote?
Everything you will pay for the same outcome over a fixed period: one-off fees, recurring fees, project or hourly charges, licenses, travel, overage and renewal increases. Compare it over 12 and 36 months, plus what you would owe if you exited early.
How is the price score calculated?
Price score = 5 x lowest total cost / this vendor's total cost, using the horizon you selected. The cheapest quote scores 5 and the others score proportionally less.
Should I always choose the cheapest quote?
No. Choose the best weighted score against criteria you set before seeing prices. When totals are within a few percent, quality, flexibility and exit terms should decide.
Is my data saved or sent anywhere?
No. The calculator runs in your browser. Your inputs are kept only in this browser's local storage so they are still there when you come back, and Start over clears them.
Can I compare quotes in different currencies?
Convert them to one currency at one dated exchange rate first. The calculator shows a warning when quotes use different currencies, because totals and price scores are not meaningful across them.